i will preface this entry with: yeah, i know i'm a dork. so yesterday i made plans to see my friend Oster (one of at least three friends i refer to by last name, i don't know why). we hadn't seen each other in what felt like forever and were way overdue. i suggested going to our usual wine bar on 7th Avenue in Chelsea. she e-mailed back, "Ehhh. There's a pub nearby, let's go there instead." i wasn't wild about the idea, but figured what the hell.
she got stuck at work so i found the place on my own - Peter McManus, it's called - on the corner of 19th and 7th. it looks normal enough from the outside, just your regular pub. the inside, however - well, as Oster put it, it's like being in an Ed Burns movie. or in a bar upstate, or somewhere in the middle of Pennsylvania. it really felt - as i texted Oster as soon as i got there - like a time warp. the place was dingy, i swear the air looked smoky even though it's illegal, and the patrons were - at least at first - 90% old men who'd clearly been drinking all day. normally i love places like this, but last night i felt painfully conspicuous and out of place. i'd been inspired that morning, for some reason, to throw on something other than my usual jeans and tee shirt for work. i'd gone all out, in fact - skirt, high boots, relatively low-cut sweater. i'd been pretty proud of the effort all day, but that pride dribbled away when i walked into McManus's. it really seemed like the music screeched to a halt when i opened the door, and all the patrons' heads swung in my direction. they stared at me as if i'd crashed their party. i half-expected one of them to ask me if i was lost.
anyway, i found an empty stool at the bar, ordered a pint and pulled out my copy of the
Daily News. Oster arrived a half-hour later and we ordered more beer and some food (if mozzarella sticks and onion rings qualify as food) and finally got to catching up. Oster and i used to go out almost every Wednesday when we worked at
Seventeen together, and carried on the tradition for a while even after we both left. our dive of choice then was Brother Jimmy's, as fratty a frat bar as you can find. Wednesday was ladies night at Bro Jo's, as we called it, and very rarely did we have an uneventful time there. last night, as McManus's started to fill in a little with all sorts of characters i said, "this is like Brother Jimmy's, for old people." she smiled her Oster smile and said, "it's Uncle Jimmy's."
a little later, we were in the middle of a conversation when in walked a tiny blond woman with a familiar face. it registered a moment later - Amy Poehler. Oster had told me that she'd seen Horatio Sanz in the bar a few times, so it was a funny coincidence that another
Saturday Night Live cast member showed up. she looked completely unassuming, very un-famous, and just sat down at a table in the bar area with a couple non-descript guys.
the thing about New York is that celebrities sort of blend in. that's apparently why so many of them come here. New Yorkers supposedly could care less, don't bother them, don't even notice them most of the time. that's me - i never really notice anyone unless i'm paying close attention, which doesn't happen very often. but seeing Amy Poehler was sort of cool because i think she's hilarious, and she's married to Will Arnett, who's even more hilarious than she is. i have to admit, the fact that Amy was there gave the place some credibility. "see?" Oster said. "i told you."
a half-hour later, Oster and i were discussing
People magazine's latest crop of Sexiest Men Alive. we agreed that we're over cover boy Clooney and quickly moved on to discussing the actual
good picks they made - Patrick Dempsey, the new guy on
Lost, Taye Digs, John Krasinski from
The Office. i was particularly gushing over John. i love
The Office, i love the character he plays, and i happen to think he's completely adorable. i swear to god, maybe 30 seconds later, while we're still discussing our sexiest picks, a few more familiar faces walk in the door - Will Arnett, Kevin Pollack, some actor who looks like a younger Paul Giamatti and - i'm not kidding -
John Krasinski. i was squeezing Oster's arm so tight, i'm sure i left a bruise.
only once in my life have i lost my mind over a famous person. i met Joey McIntyre a week before my 25th birthday - i'd been slightly obsessed with him as a pre-pubescent and couldn't resist the opportunity to see him perform in an off-Broadway show. i took a picture with him after the show, which was pretty embarrassing, but not as bad as what happened a few days later. the mortifying, pathetic, most ridiculous part was when i
mailed him the picture with a note,
inviting him to my birthday party. (he, uh, didn't show up.) i still haven't forgiven myself.
anyway. i tried extremely hard not to be a spaz last night, despite the fact that Jim from
The Office was playing Golden Tee with Gob from
Arrested Development two feet behind me. they seemed like normal guys, drinking beer, hanging out, hopefully unaware that i was gaping at them. Amy Poehler was old news by now. My heart was thumping solely for John Krasinski. not because i wanted to make-out with him or become his best friend. seriously. i'm not that nuts. it was just because this is a guy i had just been reading about on people.com earlier in the day, a guy i watch every week and absolutely love, a guy i really had not expected to see in this crappy little pub on a random Wednesday night.
i really, really wanted to ignore the situation, just keep chatting with Oster and the dorky (non-famous) guys sitting next to us. but i couldn't stop thinking that i had to do
something. i don't often find myself in such situations, and i knew i would kick myself later if i just shrugged it off and sat there. "buy him a drink," Oster suggested. i already knew he was drinking Guinness - a girl just notices these things - and i sort of liked the idea. problem was, as far as i could see, his pint was full. maybe i needed another in. i got up to go to the bathroom at one point and brushed by him on the way - not even on purpose, the pub is just pretty small - but he was deep in conversation with Amy. i sat back down on my stool afterward and vacillated: be ballsy, or be a wimp? take a chance, or go home? have a story to tell, or no story at all? i glanced back once more and John's pint was two-thirds empty.
"OK," i said to my friends at the bar, "i'll do it." i flagged down the one young, non-senile bartender and began my schpiel: "look, i know i'm a huge dork, but you know that guy over there in the navy blue shirt, he's on
The Office? i wanna buy him a beer. i'm not a stalker, i'm not a freak, i have a boyfriend i'm very happy with. i just think he's really cool." the bartender thought nothing of it, said, "no problem. he's drinking Guinness." i paid the $5, the bartender filled the pint glass, and took it to John, who was sitting in a booth in the back by then with the rest of the group, out of my line of vision. the bartender came back a minute later and said, "John said that was really sweet of you. i told him where you're sitting." i smiled and thanked him and tried to appear calm, but my heart was pounding like crazy.
"that was really brave of you," Oster told me. "i
know!" i said, still a little amazed that i'd done it. all i could think was that i'm getting pretty bold in my old age. i was a little bit proud of myself. i mean, i used to be the shyest, most play-it-safe girl. now, i'm buying beers for guys on TV. "if he's a true gentleman," Oster was saying, in the middle of my reverie, "he'll come thank you, or ask the bartender what you're drinking and buy
you a beer." i gasped. "No! Oster, i'm drinking
Bud Lite!" as fast as i could get the bartender's attention, i ordered a Bass.
maybe 15 or 20 minutes later, while Oster and I were engrossed in another conversation, i felt a hand on my back. "are you the one who bought me the Guinness?" just like that John Krasinski was standing there, talking to me, asking my name, offering me his hand - "I'm John," he said - and oh was i so happy i'd dressed up that morning instead of my usual jeans and a tee shirt. he was saying, "that was really cool of you, thank you so much. that was so nice," and i was saying, "no problem, you're welcome, i think you're great." i asked him if he was hosting
SNL this week, if that's why he was hanging out with those guys and he said, "no, but i should be, right?" in an incredibly goofy, adorable way - he came off exactly like Jim, actually - and then he explained that he goes way back with Amy and Will, and they were all just hanging out. i told him i couldn't believe the place when i walked in (and Oster got in her line about being in an Ed Burns movie) and that it was so funny to see familiar faces there. he said he hated clubs, much prefers places like this, always sticks to places like McManus when he's in New York. "i was impressed that you knew i was drinking Guinness," he said to me. "i wasn't stalking you, i swear, i just noticed," i told him, which Oster made fun of me for later ("you could have just said you asked the bartender what he was drinking!") but he said, "no, no, it was really cool." he had his coat on, i figured he was taking off, so he thanked me again, i said it was great meeting him, and that was it.
the amazing thing was, i didn't stumble over a single word. i didn't say anything embarrassing, i didn't drool on myself, or on him. i was just thrilled. thrilled that i'd been brave, thrilled that he'd come up to thank me, so thrilled that he was such a nice, normal guy. we left the bar a little later, and i couldn't wipe the smile off my face for anything. "aren't you glad we came here?" Oster gloated as we walked out. "yeah, yeah, yeah," i grumbled.
then i looked at her. "you know we're coming here every Wednesday now, right?"
mb